You can’t say that!

25 08 2009

no voiceThe online space has created an unrestrained and unaccountable voice – until recently.

More and more frequently, we are beginning to see people being held responsible for their words and actions online. Online forums, social networks, online communities  – have all enabled the public to voice their words to a much larger audience than ever before. It’s much easier to voice ones opinions or views, hidden behind the anonymity of a screen name, and a faceless computer screen.

But with issues like cyber bullying becoming a frequent problem, the question needs to be asked – should we allow people total freedom of speech online?

Should people be held accountable for what they say on the web?

Already we are seeing an increase in the percentage of employers checking the online profiles of prospective and current employees – with the drunk and disorderly soon finding themselves without a job. 45% of employers to be exact.

We also saw Lori Drew, the Missouri mother who saw criminal charges being laid against her, after she had created a false profile on MySpace, which she then used to taunt and make cruel comments about one of her daughter’s friends, Megan Meir. These actions resulted in her suicide shortly after.

How simple is it to create numerous and anonymous identities online?

Is it appropriate to hold people accountable when they misuse these profiles?

Some seem to believe that it’s not, with rights groups becoming nervous that more cases of this kind will challenge a threat to free speech. Last year the EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation), Center for Democracy & Technology, Public Citizen and 14 other law professors, filed an amicus brief, purporting that the charges against Lauri Drew:

“The groups argue that, while the events were tragic, holding the mom criminally responsible could have “dangerous ramifications” for all US citizens who use the Internet.” (Source: Ars Tecnica)

While we praise the web 2.0 for ensuring that companies are being held responsible for their actions – are we comfortable with the developing notion of ‘free speech’ online? Tiphereth Gloria also discusses this in Social Media Accountability is a two way street.

The recent case involving Google and disgruntled model Lisuka Cohen – saw the landmark decision that forced Google to reveal the identity of the anonymous ‘Skanks of NYC’ blogger. While the (not so tough anymore) blogger plans to sue Google for the loss of anonymity, it seem that your poisoned comments are no longer safe online, ey?



3 responses

26 08 2009
Twitter Trackbacks for You can’t say that! « Community Girl [] on

[…] You can’t say that! « Community Girl – view page – cached #RSS 2.0 Community Girl » You can’t say that! Comments Feed Community Girl ad:tech 09 What the F**K is Social Media: One Year Later — From the page […]

28 08 2009

It is a strange world we live in. More and more I see people thinking they can just say whatever they want online. It erodes the concept of respect and makes the internet a very spiteful place. People should be absolutely help accountable for what they say online.

“… holding the mom criminally responsible could have dangerous ramifications”. Oh lets protect the poor online profiles of people because protecting a young girls life is not worth it – get some perspective.

Lots of bloggers/experts believe we are all publishers and all have content and we are all connected. This is bullshit – sure the opportunity is there but not everyone ahs something valuable to say.

28 08 2009

Thanks for your comment Daniel. I also believe that people should be held accountable for what they say and do online, offline – wherever.
While the world wide web has opened up many new avenues for people to have a voice, I think you’re right in saying that we can’t allow people complete freedom to say whatever spiteful/hurtful/bigoted/racist/homophobic/narrow minded thought that enters their mind – without consequences.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: